Honda Replaces Failed 2017 Pilot Engine Free
Owners of out-of-warranty Honda vehicles with rod-bearing failures may find public pressure can prompt free engine replacement.
Updated on Nov. 2, 2026 in Car Maintenance
Live Poll
Do you trust carmakers to cover major repairs when a defect appears after warranty?
Honda agreed to replace the rod-bearing-failed engine in a 2017 Honda Pilot owned by Ellie Shea at no charge, after initially declining to contribute citing the expired warranty. Honda did not admit fault, and the family's case drew attention from local media and Maryland lawmakers.
Why it matters
Owners of 2017 Pilots facing costly engine repairs outside warranty may have limited recourse without public pressure, since the repair estimate exceeded the value of a replacement vehicle. The case also underscores that NHTSA's ongoing rod-bearing investigation covers about 1.4 million Honda and Acura V6 vehicles, and the 2023 recall excluded 2017 models.
Ellie Shea's 2017 Honda Pilot had 56,000 miles when its rod bearing failed, and the repair estimate exceeded the cost of buying another 2017 Pilot. Honda reversed its initial refusal to contribute after media coverage and letters from Senator Chris Van Hollen and Representative Jamie Raskin.
The players
Honda
Japanese automaker whose Pilot and Acura V6 lineups are central to NHTSA's rod-bearing investigation and 2023 recall.
NHTSA
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, the federal agency that investigates vehicle defects and oversees recalls.
Chris Van Hollen
U.S. Senator from Maryland who wrote to NHTSA and Honda on the Sheas' behalf.
Jamie Raskin
U.S. Representative from Maryland who wrote to NHTSA and Honda and pressed Honda with six questions about the failure.
The details
Rod-bearing failure is an internal engine fault that NHTSA has been investigating across roughly 1.4 million Honda and Acura V6 vehicles. Honda initially declined to help pay for the repair, pointing to the expired warranty. After 7News covered the family's situation and the lawmakers wrote to NHTSA and Honda, Honda agreed to collect the failed engine and install a replacement at no charge. Representative Raskin also asked Honda to answer six questions about the failure and the refusal to pay.
Timeline
2023: NHTSA recall covering about 250,000 vehicles from model years 2016, 2018, and 2019 was issued, excluding 2017 models.
The Shea family pursued the repair over a yearlong struggle before receiving the free replacement.
Nov. 2, 2026: Article describing Honda's free engine replacement was published.
The Home Front
Car owners in Maryland and across the country rely on recall protection that can exclude specific model years, as the 2023 Honda recall did for 2017 Pilots. This case shows how an out-of-warranty engine failure can become a household budget crisis when a repair estimate rivals the price of a replacement vehicle.
If you own a 2016–2019 Honda Pilot or a Honda or Acura V6 vehicle, check whether your model year is covered by the NHTSA recall or investigation before scheduling an engine repair. Bring any warranty or service records to a licensed Honda dealer and ask about goodwill assistance on an out-of-warranty engine failure.
The takeaway
Owners outside the warranty period can still pursue manufacturer help when repair costs approach the value of the vehicle, as the Shea family did. Keep service records on file and check your VIN against NHTSA's recall database at nhtsa.gov before paying for major engine work.
Further reading
For more on keeping vehicles running, see Car Maintenance coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Cool Down.
Live Poll
Do you trust carmakers to cover major repairs when a defect appears after warranty?
