Chicago Officer Retained After Shooting Resident Dog
A 2024 incident involving a dog owner has led to calls for termination that remain unresolved.
Updated on Sept. 25, 2026 in Dogs
Live Poll
Do you trust your local police department to hold officers accountable for confirmed misconduct?
In April 2024, Chicago police officer Carmen Mostek shot and killed a dog named Aggie while the animal was being held by its owner, Kent Maynard. Despite recommendations for termination, the officer remains employed by the department.
Why it matters
The case highlights concerns regarding police use of force and the administrative processes governing officer accountability. It remains a point of contention for local residents and pet owners following the loss of a pet in this incident.
COPA recommended that Officer Carmen Mostek be fired for improper use of force and false statements regarding the April 2024 shooting. The police board currently maintains that no disciplinary case exists because formal charges were never filed.
The players
Carmen Mostek
A Chicago police officer who remains on duty following an April 2024 incident involving the shooting of a pet.
Kent Maynard
The owner of the dog named Aggie who was holding the animal when it was shot.
Larry Snelling
The former Chicago police superintendent who supported the recommendation to fire the officer involved in the shooting.
The details
The incident occurred when the officer fired her weapon at the dog while it was being held by its owner. The officer claimed the action was taken to protect her own corgi during the encounter. While former Superintendent Larry Snelling supported the recommendation to terminate the officer in January 2026, the officer remains employed and is currently detailed to the Alternate Response Section.
Timeline
The shooting of the dog occurred in April 2024.
The former Superintendent supported termination in January 2026.
The Home Front
This case highlights the procedural complexities within the Chicago Police Department disciplinary systems. It follows a pattern of administrative friction between civilian oversight bodies and internal board requirements.
Pet owners should remain aware of local policies regarding animal control and public safety interactions. If you are involved in an incident with law enforcement, document all details immediately and consult with a legal professional regarding your rights.
The takeaway
Accountability in local public safety incidents remains tied to the specific status of disciplinary filings. Residents should monitor the progress of the pending civil case for any updates on the final legal resolution of this matter.
Further reading
For more information on pet safety and community resources in the city, see Dogs.
Source note: This article includes information reported by CBS News.
Live Poll
Do you trust your local police department to hold officers accountable for confirmed misconduct?
